One
day, it just happens. You completely snap. Your last single friend announces
her engagement to the schmo she met two months ago, or your married boss hits
on you just when you think you've managed to impress him with your work smarts,
or you're forced off the sidewalk by a J.Crew couple and their double-barreled
baby stroller. It's all too much. It might not be dramatica sudden freak-out
or breakdown. It could simply be the cumulative effect of watching the world
surge past and around you-the showers, the weddings, the new houses, the better
jobs, the damn baby photos. Everyone else seems to know what she wantsand how
to get ityet you consistently feel overlooked, underloved, and, let's face
it, screwed, in every way except literally.
You
know you shouldn't feel this way. You don't want to become some whiney
malcontent. But you can't shake this unresolved restlessness, this nameless
dissatisfaction with your life. You've tried to put it in perspectivethere's
real tragedy in the world, real crisis and painyou know, you know, you know.
You know Fran the receptionist still aches for her husband, dead ten years, and
you watched your friend Meg fight a brutal, losing battle with cancer. You've
seen what illness and death and estrangement can do. You carry all sorts of
loss within you.
That's
why the baby stroller people or the smarmy boss or the schmo-marrying friend
put you right over the edgeyou're tired of losing people and losing hope. You
feel a great longing for companionship and connectedness, for knowing that what
you do means something, for gratification and peace of mind, but it keeps
eluding you despite your best efforts. And every reminder of this longing cuts
into your spirit again and again until you just can't take it. When will you stop
feeling so bereft, mourning what you've lost (friends, true loves, your
mother's approval) and what you've never had (the little household of your
dreams, a soul-fulfilling vocation, your mother's approval)?
One way
to start feeling better is to give yourself permission to kick and wail and
grieve. Let the poets in Hurting help you express all of itthe rage, the
despair, the what-am-I-doing-with-my-life agony. Think of this section as one
big scream of frustration. All we know is that we just feel pain, the kind that
comes from being scraped in the same place over and over again. Like the
speaker in Lola Haskins's "Love," we're raw with feeling,
oversensitized to everything that's ever hurt us. We don't know quite what's
hit us, we just feel our skin's been ripped off.
But
deep down, we really do know what's hit uscrushing disappointment after
disappointment. Some big (your parents were supposed to stay together forever),
some small (that cellulite was supposed to disappear after you went off the
Pill), and some that we try to say are small when we know they're really big
(we were supposed to have snagged The One, flex-timed The Job, and delivered
The Kids before The Fertility Plunge). Tack on general injustice, poverty, and
terror, and you feel too bruised to bear it.
What
gets us is the "why" of it all. Why us? Did we ask for any of this?
Weren't we entitled to something else? The speaker in Dorothy Parker's
ironically named "Fulfillment" seems incredulous that this kind of
pain is her reward for becoming a reasonably well-raised adult. "For this
my mother wrapped me warm . . . And gave me roughage in my diet"? she
asks. All so I could "grow to womanhood" and "break my heart to
clattering bits"?
Talk
about roughage in the dietwhen you feel this forsaken, every disappointment
seems too tough to digest. And we make matters worse by chewing each one to
death! Somehow, perversely, we feed our own despair. We keep careful track of
every little thing that has hurt us, we nurse our grudges, we stay in the very situations
that bring us down.
Look at
the lovers in Anna Akhmatova's "We Don't Know How to Say Goodbye."
The two of them are a picture of gloomhe's moody, she's his shadow, and
they're sitting on a frozen branch in a graveyard outside a church where masses
for the dead are being said. Not exactly a Harlequin romance! So why are they
still together? If she wants to stop feeling "so different from the
rest"if, like a lot of women we know, she wants a sunny bungalow of
family happinessthen why is she willing to settle for his stick picture of a
mansion in the snow? Why can't she find a way to say goodbye?
Maybe
it's because she can't conceive of any identity for herself outside of him.
Maybe it's because some relationships are just too difficult to severyou
can't just cut your father or your boss out of your life, no matter how
"moody" (try "abusive") they are, can you? Or your oldest
friend? Sometimes staying stuck in misery seems easier than razing your old
life and building a new one.
Perhaps
that's why the woman in Deborah Garrison's "Worked Late on a Tuesday
Night" is alone and forlorn in the deserted streets, trying with no
success to hail a cab home. This is not the first time she's been here, cold
but "too stubborn to reach/into [her] pocket for a glove." Seems
she's too stubborn to reach, period. For protection from the cold or for a
better life than what she's got. She knows she's "not half/of what [she]
meant to be," so why doesn't she change her life instead of just
"cursing/the freezing rain"?
Why?
Because of a little thing called pride. Who wants to admit, "My life is a
disaster, and every little part of me feels broken!"? We made the choices
that led us here. We never meant to be alone and heartsick, but we did choose
this job, this city, these relationships. We thought we were building a life
for ourselves; now we're supposed to realize that instead we were slowly
crumbling inside, helping along the decay of our ovaries and the dilapidation
of our souls, à la Emily Dickinson's "Crumbling Is Not an Instant's
Act"? That's outrageous and unfair and infuriating. How could we have
known it would all work out this way? What should we have done differently?
And
even if you do swallow your pride, even if you do admit you feel used up and
useless, like the gum-decayed mother in Elizabeth Ash Velez's "Thursday,
11:00 A.M.," or smushy and rotten like a pear spoiled "from the
inside out" in Jane Kenyon's "The Pear"then what? You're
supposed to have the strength and wherewithal to just chuck everything and start
over?: "Okay, this life sucks, so hmmm, I know what I'll doI'll just
quit my job and move somewhere perfect and do something much better, never mind
that I haven't a clue where to go, what to do, or how to pay for any of it!
Yippee, it's a plan!"
Not
likely. At this point in Hurting all we know is that we've had enough, and
we're too defensive and confused to do much about it. So instead of radically
changing the big things in our lives, we usually opt for making last-ditch
efforts to change the superficial things. Maybe if we tightened our torso, we'd
feel more in control, so it's off to Pilates class. Maybe if those frown lines
disappeared, we'd feel less anxious, so it's off to the BOTOX doc. Like the
girlchild in Marge Piercy's "Barbie Doll," we run "to and fro
apologizing" to ourselves for not being the person we always dreamed we'd
be. As if we're offering one last desperate sacrifice to the God of Happiness,
we cut off our noses to spite ourselves. There, I've done everything I can, we
think. Now give me a better life!
And
when no better life materializes, we truly fall into the kind of despair
William Butler Yeats describes in "The Second Coming." We can't fix
ourselves, we decide, because everything falls apartour bodies, our lives,
the world. No center holds anything together; it's all anarchy. So why bother
trying to be the "beauty of the world, the paragon of animals," why
bother trying to be some perfect Gap person in a shiny little Pottery Barn
life? Like Hamlet, we tell ourselves there's no point. The world is nothing but
a "foul and pestilent congregation of vapors," and we amount to
nothing but a "quintessence of dust."
Okay,
fine then, you think. I'll stop trying to please everyone else. I'll stop
blaming myself for everything wrong in my life. I'll stop worrying about the
misery of the world. Who needs any of it, anywaythe sea and trees, red ripe
tomatoes, office blowhards, artsy posers? As poet Deborah Garrison eloquently
says, "Fuck them all" ("Fight Song"). Or as poet Etheridge
Knight more delicately puts it, "fuck/the whole mothafucking thing"
("Feeling Fucked Up").
So!
Terrific! The Hurting poets have done such a good job of expressing all your
sorrow and outrage that here you are feeling like a one big F-word piece of
dust. This is supposed to make you feel better?
Well,
we think it's a startat least you're acknowledging your pain. It's real, and
it hurts, and you're sick of it. The trick is how to move on from here.
What
you don't want to do is stay trapped in this fuck-you frame of mind. If you
isolate and alienate yourself from the world, you'll become the creature in
Stephen Crane's "The Heart," squatting in a desert of your own making
(like an angry loser on Survivor). Sure things were bad before when you were
sitting in that cold graveyard or being pelted by the freezing rainbut is
this really an improvement? You've felt frustrated in your efforts to evolve
into a fulfilled, happy person, but did you really mean to devolve into thisa
naked, bestial monster eating its own bitter heart out?
Of
course not. Ultimately what you want is what the speaker in Knight's poem is
pining forsomething and someone to love, so that "[your] soul can
sing." Allow yourself to rantfuck 'em allbut then get out of Hurting,
fast. If you want gg to love life again, you'll need that heart of yours, and
the less bitter, the better.
Love
She tries it on, like a dress.
She decides it doesn't fit,
and starts to take it off.
Her skin comes, too.
Lola Haskins
Fulfillment
For this my mother wrapped me warm,
And called me home against the storm,
And coaxed my infant nights to quiet,
And gave me roughage in my diet,
And tucked me in my bed at eight,
And clipped my hair, and marked my weight,
And watched me as I sat and stood:
That I might grow to womanhood
To hear a whistle and drop my wits
And break my heart to clattering bits.